- Thread starter
- #101
K
Kerry Brown
"Stinger" <Stinger@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:B7A45133-F148-4507-85CB-> Bottom line, this update is important since
it was a gapping hole in Windows
> for quite some time. Great that Windows decided to do something about it.
> Bad it renders tried and true helper 3rd party software that has been used
> for years by the general public trying its best to close that huge hole in
> Windows (with what is considered "overkill) and at the same time
> consumers
> are unable to even get on the internet without a single word of caution
> from
> the makers of the operating system. Ironically, they left it up to the
> geeks
> of the world to figure it out. Nice from a company that assumes it's the
> industry leader.
You should do a bit of research before you post. The gaping hole was in the
way DNS worked. It was not Windows specific. Almost every OS was affected.
In fact almost everything that interacted with DNS in any way was affected.
http://www.securityfocus.com/news/11526
Take a look at some of the affected products.
http://www.kb.cert.org/vuls/id/800113
We can debate the effectiveness of software firewalls all day. I don't think
at the end of the debate either of us would change their mind. You think
they're great. I think they're mostly hype and snake oil. There is no
debating the fact that this flaw in the DNS system needed to be patched and
it needed to be patched immediately. This has nothing to do with Windows.
The flaw was in the way DNS worked. The fact that your 3rd party application
couldn't deal with the fact that an OS update changed some system files says
a lot about how well it's programmed. It wasn't any changes in the files
that broke your software. It was just the fact that the files changed that
broke it. If an application can't deal with the fact that an OS may update
itself it's not an application I would want on my computer.
--
Kerry Brown
MS-MVP - Windows Desktop Experience: Systems Administration
http://www.vistahelp.ca/phpBB2/
http://vistahelpca.blogspot.com/
news:B7A45133-F148-4507-85CB-> Bottom line, this update is important since
it was a gapping hole in Windows
> for quite some time. Great that Windows decided to do something about it.
> Bad it renders tried and true helper 3rd party software that has been used
> for years by the general public trying its best to close that huge hole in
> Windows (with what is considered "overkill) and at the same time
> consumers
> are unable to even get on the internet without a single word of caution
> from
> the makers of the operating system. Ironically, they left it up to the
> geeks
> of the world to figure it out. Nice from a company that assumes it's the
> industry leader.
You should do a bit of research before you post. The gaping hole was in the
way DNS worked. It was not Windows specific. Almost every OS was affected.
In fact almost everything that interacted with DNS in any way was affected.
http://www.securityfocus.com/news/11526
Take a look at some of the affected products.
http://www.kb.cert.org/vuls/id/800113
We can debate the effectiveness of software firewalls all day. I don't think
at the end of the debate either of us would change their mind. You think
they're great. I think they're mostly hype and snake oil. There is no
debating the fact that this flaw in the DNS system needed to be patched and
it needed to be patched immediately. This has nothing to do with Windows.
The flaw was in the way DNS worked. The fact that your 3rd party application
couldn't deal with the fact that an OS update changed some system files says
a lot about how well it's programmed. It wasn't any changes in the files
that broke your software. It was just the fact that the files changed that
broke it. If an application can't deal with the fact that an OS may update
itself it's not an application I would want on my computer.
--
Kerry Brown
MS-MVP - Windows Desktop Experience: Systems Administration
http://www.vistahelp.ca/phpBB2/
http://vistahelpca.blogspot.com/